The 1964 nickel face value is $0.05, but if you have a unique item, you can sell it for $100 and more dollars on the eBay online platform and auctions. Do not remember about fees and certifications.
1964 Nickel Overview
The 1964 Jefferson piece represents a notable period in American history. This particular coin signaled the conclusion of a significant chapter for the United States Mint while simultaneously signaling a shift in production techniques and design approaches.
| Year | 1964 |
| Diameter | 21.20 mm |
| Weight | 5.00 g |
| Edge | Plain |
| Composition | 75 % Copper |
Why Is It not Easy to Sell a 1964 Jefferson Nickel?
Several factors influence the item’s selling:
- Total mintage is over 2.8 billion
- It is not easy to find rare varieties such as SMS or FS
- Competition on the online platforms
GreatCollections Coin Auctions
Ian Russell founded GreatCollections in 2010, and it now serves as a preferred online auction house for certified coins. This platform enforces a strict policy: sellers can only list coins that independent grading services evaluate.
They accept coins from:
- The Professional Coin Grading Service or PCGS
- Numismatic Guaranty Company or NGC
- American Numismatic Association Certification Service or ANACS
If you hold a 1964 nickel with verified Full Steps or a confirmed Doubled Die, GreatCollections places your coin in front of serious collectors who trust third-party certification.
Fee Structures and Processing Times
GreatCollections attracts sellers through its cost-effective fee model:
The company charges a seller fee of just 5% for coins that sell for less than $1,000.
For coins above $1,000, the seller fee drops to 0%.
This model beats traditional auction houses. Once the hammer falls on your 1964 nickel, GreatCollections processes payments quickly. They mail checks or initiate direct deposits within seven to ten business days after the auction closes.
Consignment Perks for Elite Coins
If you possess a raw 1964 nickel that shows potential for a high grade, GreatCollections offers a consignment program. You can ship your raw coin directly to their headquarters.
Their team analyzes the coin, utilizes their bulk corporate discounts to submit it to PCGS or NGC, and then places the certified coin into their weekly auctions. This program removes the logistical headache of independent coin submission.
eBay
eBay remains the largest online marketplace for coins in the world. On any given day, millions of active watchlists monitor coin categories. This massive traffic makes eBay a powerful tool if you want to sell 1964 nickel varieties that lack professional certification. You retain complete control over your listing, choose your terms, and interact directly with the buyer pool.
Auction vs. Fixed-Price Formats for 1964 Nickel Errors
| Selling Format | Best for |
| The Auction Format | Striking errors;Struck on a copper penny blank;50 % off-center strikes |
| The Fixed-Price Format | Standard die varieties;Repunched Mint Marks (RPM) |
The Auction Format benefit is that the intense visual shock of a major error often triggers competitive bidding wars among collectors, driving up the final payout. The Fixed-Price Format provides a safety net that prevents your item from selling too low if player turnout or bidder traffic drops during a specific week.
Evaluating the Final Value Fees and Shipping Risks
Sellers must calculate the high cost of eBay transactions. The platform takes a final value fee of 13.25 % plus a flat fee of $0.30 per order for most coin categories.
To protect sellers from chargebacks, eBay runs a coin authentication program for high-value items. If your coin sells for more than a set threshold, you ship it to an independent expert first. This expert verifies the listing details before the package travels to the final buyer.
Heritage Auctions
Heritage Auctions stands as the largest numismatic auctioneer in the world. This house handles museum-quality items and historical treasures. If you discover a legitimate 1964 SMS nickel, you should not list it on a standard retail website.
You need the prestige of an establishment that routinely shatters world records. Heritage previously handled the sale of a 1964 SMS nickel for $32,900 because they know how to attract elite buyers.
How the Consignment Process Works
The journey at Heritage begins with a formal evaluation. You contact an auction specialist and present your certified coin.
Once they accept your 1964 nickel, their staff creates a professional catalog description, utilizes high-resolution macro photography, and includes the coin in an upcoming signature auction. They market these auctions globally through printed catalogs and digital promotional campaigns months in advance.
Stack’s Bowers Galleries
Stack’s Bowers Galleries began operations in 1933. They hold a historic status as an official auction sponsor for the American Numismatic Association. This legacy gives them immense credibility among senior collectors.
When you sell through Stack’s Bowers, the marketplace knows that an elite team verified the physical integrity of your 1964 Jefferson nickel.
Direct Cash Purchase Programs vs. Global Auction Inclusion
| Selling Pathway | Recommended Use Case |
| Direct Cash Purchase | Sellers who require immediate funds;Standard or lower-premium 1964 nickels |
| Global Auction Inclusion | Sellers looking to maximize final value;High-grade Full Steps or rare 1964 varieties |
With the direct cash purchase, you can bring or ship your coin to their retail galleries in New York, Boston, or Philadelphia for an immediate, hassle-free cash payout from their on-site numismatists.
With global auction inclusion, you consign the coin into high-profile global showcase auctions, where specialist collectors directly compete against one another via live internet feeds.
Local NGC & PCGS Authorized Retail Dealers
If you want to avoid shipping risks, online payment processors, and wait times, look for a local brick-and-mortar coin shop. You must ensure the shop holds an official authorization from PCGS or NGC.
A local shop is an excellent venue for common uncirculated coins or minor D Repunched Mint Marks. You walk into the storefront, hand the dealer the coin, and walk out with cash within minutes.
Wholesale and Retail Pricing Reality
Sellers must understand the business model of a retail dealer. A store owner carries:
- Overhead costs
- Insurance premiums
- Employee wages
They cannot pay you the full retail price listed in guidebooks. They buy at wholesale prices so they can resell the coin at retail value later.
If a pricing guide lists your 1964 nickel error at $100, a local dealer will likely offer $60 to $70. You trade a percentage of your profit for immediate safety and convenience.
adnimda